Q: In school we learned that primary waves can travel through solids,
liquids, and gases. My question is: what would happen if a
P-wave was
traveling through the ground and it reached a canyon and a bird was in the air
when the wave started traveling through the air? Would the bird be affected?
(Teddy, Charlottesville, Virginia)
A magnitude 6.9 earthquake tumbled this cabin in the Santa Cruz Mountains
about 60 miles from San Francisco. [J.K. Nakata, U.S. Geological Survey]
A:
The bird would probably not notice the p-wave. Here’s a likely scenario based on
information from experts:
Offshore of central California, a fault along the ocean floor cracks as the
North American and Pacific plates move minutely. A small (magnitude 3.4)
earthquake results and waves flow through the Earth and along its surface,
releasing the fault’s pent-up energy.
The P-wave travels fast: reaching San Francisco in 40 seconds, Wichita,
Kansas in 4 minutes, and rattling through the Earth’s core to reach Nairobi,
Kenya in 16 minutes. The wave hustles along like a sound wave, moving dirt and
rock only a tiny distance as the disturbance zips past.
Back at California, near its source: The wave first travels down into the
earth and bends upward as it gets into Earth’s deeper layers. As the wave moves
up towards the surface, Earth absorbs and dissipates frequencies high enough for
most animals to hear. The almost-vertically traveling wave makes it to the
surface at the canyon. It bounces back from Earth’s surface. Only a small
fraction of its energy crosses into canyon air. A low amplitude, low frequency
(perhaps 1 to 20 Hz) wave continues. The canyon remains quiet (except for a
small whisper of oak leaves as trees tremble). A band tailed pigeon, beating her
wings upward, hears the incredibly low sound but pays no attention. She hears
too much non-threatening noise at these frequencies to listen.
The experts who contributed to this answer are:
Andrew Michael geologist at
Menlo Park, California Earthquake’s Hazards Team of the U.S. Geological Survey
and
Charles Walcott, neurobiology professor and faculty dean at Cornell
University.
Further Reading:
San Diego State University: Earthquakes and their waves
USGS: Magnitude
3.4 offshore central California, theoretical P-wave travel times
Sinking balloons
Q:
My daughter put her helium balloon in the bath with her and now it won’t float.
Do you know why? (
Palmer Eagle)
A: The balloon won’t float because of the weight of the water clinging to it.
Towel it off and watch it rise again. At least, that’s what happened to my
balloon.
Helium balloons reaching for the sky. [Lanney Atchley]
Further Reading:
WonderQuest: Toy balloons are full of holes
Speeding cars
Q: Your answer about the car traveling at "near-light speed" made me wonder
about two, no three, more things. Ok, the light from the car travels at light
speed relative to the car. But, doesn't this then mean that the light from the
car is traveling faster than the speed of light relative to the rest of the
universe outside the car? And if this is possibly true, does an object traveling
at near-light speed create its own universe? And can the speed of light in this
universe be exceeded in another universe, relative to this one?
(Love your column; thanks very much! Andrew, Muscat, Oman)
A:
Light from the car travels at light speed relative to the car and
relative to a hitchhiker walking along the road, watching the speeding car go
by. Light travels at light speed with respect to any frame of reference.
The speed of light in a vacuum is a constant. That’s an absolute.
Nothing travels faster than light [JSC/NASA]
So, the car’s light does not travel faster than the speed of light relative
to the rest of the Universe. It’s a good question, though, that bothered eminent
scientists before you. Even Newton’s principles of mechanics allowed a force to
accelerate an object to any speed with no upper limit. It took Einstein’s genius
to figure out that light travels at a constant speed and no object travels
faster.
It may also be true that many universes exist with perhaps different laws of
physics. This, though, takes us beyond Einstein’s general theory of relativity
(that we’ve checked in many different ways) into physics frontiers.
(Answered May 21, 2004)