Can hot water freeze faster than cold?
It can happen. But scientists have yet to figure out
exactly why
Which freezes faster — cold water or boiling water?
Hailey, Sprighill, Florida
 Usually cold water freezes before hot, as Newton
theorized in 1701. But, hot water — even boiling water — can
freeze faster than cold.
Photo from the video and courtesy of Mount Washington Observatory.
You Tube shows a
video of
university student Jim Sage on top of Mount
Washington in heavy winter clothes boiling water on
a small alcohol stove in the -34.8 F (-37.1 C) cold. Jim lifts the pot,
and tosses boiling-hot water up then watches it snow down, like a blizzard, all around him.
That's fast freezing, but faster than cold water? It can
happen, as Erasto B. Mpemba discovered in 1967 when he was a form-3
student (equivalent to North American 11th grade) making
ice cream at Magamba Secondary School in Lushoto, a small town in Tanzania, Africa.
Erasto
asked his science teacher to explain why his hot milk froze faster than a
friend's cold milk. The teacher said, "You were confused; that cannot
happen." Erasto must have had some reservations
about this reply because, over the next couple of years, he asked the same question of two more physics teachers, finally finding
one with an open mind.
Erasto's day of discovery started like most school days. He woke up
before dawn. Pulling on his school-uniform navy-blue shorts, he shivered in the cold. But the afternoon would be
hot, this close to the equator, even though he was almost a mile high in the mountains. "I've
time to make ice cream," he thought, and set out for milk.
He strode briskly along the dirt main street of Lushoto to the open-air
market. Quickly he bought some milk, and headed back to school. He mixed sugar with
milk, and put the pot on the stove to boil. It had begun to boil,
when he noticed another boy not bothering to heat his mixture
in order to seize space in the refrigerator's freezing compartment. Erasto grabbed the last available space, putting his boiling-hot
liquid
beside the cool one.
"The other boy and I went back in an hour and a half later, and found that my
tray of milk had frozen into ice-cream while his was only a thick liquid,
not yet frozen," Erasto wrote later. Erasto asked his physics professor why, and got only 'that cannot happen' answer.
Two years later, in Mkwawa High School, Erasto again asked
why the hot liquid froze faster
than the cold. His new teacher answered: You were confused.
But help was coming. The school's headmaster invited physicist Dennis
Osborne of the University College in Dar es Saalam to lecture and answer
questions. Erasto asked his question yet again.
Dr. Osborne smiled into Erasto's earnest face. "Is it true, have you
done it?"
"Yes."
Everyday events are seldom as simple as they seem, mused Osborne to himself.
"I do not know, but I promise to try this experiment." And he did,
eventually getting similar results. Osborne found cold water near 20 degrees C
(70 F) began to freeze in about 100 minutes; whereas hot water about 80 degrees C
(175 F) began to
freeze much quicker — in 40 minutes.
Water, a commonplace substance is anything but simple. Certainly, as
Mpemba and Osborne discovered, its
freezing behavior is not characterized by its average
temperature.
No doubt, several mechanisms underlie the Mpemba effect. We have
eliminated some.
For example, a vessel containing initially hot water would melt frost on
the floor of a non-frost-free refrigerator. Then, the hot-water vessel
would be in direct
contact with the cooling element of the freezer, and therefore freeze faster
than the vessel with the initially cold water, which would rest on frost.
The frost would insulate the cold-water vessel.
But, this mechanism doesn't explain the entire effect, because, in one
experiment, Osborne placed both
vessels on good thermal insulators. The hot water still froze faster than
the cold.
Osborn thought perhaps evaporation could account for the hot water freezing
faster, since the more active hot-water molecules would escape the liquid,
cooling the remaining liquid. But he found only small changes in volume due to evaporation, and
concluded evaporation could account for no more than 30 percent of the cooling.
Three
mechanisms remain that could explain the effect.
Hot-top. Cooling occurs mainly from the top surface. But
hot water freezes differently than cold — more heat escapes from the top
for hot than cold water.
Cold water starts to freeze along its top surface, and along
its sides. The top ice insulates the water from the colder air above,
slowing freezing. The insulated upper water does not chill appreciably
more and, therefore, does not become denser and drop to the bottom. Few
convection currents form, so little convective heat transfer occurs.
Hot water also freezes along the sides and bottom like the
cold water, but the top hot surface remains free of ice. Heat
radiates from the liquid top at a much higher rate than from the top ice surface
of the cold water. Moreover, many more hot water molecules zip out of the
top hot water than from the cold ice. So, the temperature drops
faster in the initially hot water.
Furthermore, in the hot vessel, as the hot surface water chills, contracts and becomes
denser, it drops to the bottom of the container and forces warmer bottom
water to the surface, further driving the heat transfer. These effects
can combine so hot water
freezes faster than cold.
Supercooling. Water has the property of
remaining liquid below its freezing-point temperature — it can become supercooled. Both the initially hot and the initially cold
water can supercool. But, if the cold water stays liquid to a lower
temperature, then the supercooled hot water may, indeed,
freeze first. Furthermore, supercooling is somewhat capricious, since it
depends upon tiny bubbles to kick off ice crystal formation. So, which
freezes faster can depend on how many
bubbles are present in the respective containers.
Snap freezing. Hot water out of a hot water heater may have
fewer of the tiny bubbles needed to form ice crystals. So, the hot water could supercool
and suddenly snap freeze, thus beating the cold water to a frozen state.
But, as physicist Monwhea Jeng of
Syracuse University writes, "There is no well-agreed explanation for how this phenomenon
occurs." Mpemba's question remains unanswered, so far.
You, too, can check this phenomenon out in your very own kitchen. If
you do, please email me your results. I'll post them with this article on
the WonderQuest site.
Earlier, I sent the article to physicist
Erik Ramberg of Fermilab for fact checks.
He emailed me back:
"I had heard these stories before about hot water freezing faster, but always
dismissed them. But the essence of science is experimentation and observation,
so I did a few simple experiments.
"I took two small containers of tap water
(about 150 ml) and covered them with lids. I heated one in the microwave for 1
minute, yielding about 170 degrees F (77 C) water. The other was room temperature -
about 70 degrees F (21 C). I fully expected the cool water to freeze much faster. To my
surprise, although the cool water developed thicker ice on the top and side
surfaces after an hour, the hotter water caught up after about 3 hours. I saw
no significant difference between the two after 4 hours in the freezer.
"I repeated the experiment twice more —
once with only 60 ml of water. The
conclusion was the same: the cooler water developed thicker ice to begin with,
but for all practical purposes the hot and cool water freeze solid after the
same amount of time. A wonderful surprise!
"I suspect the hot water radiates its heat quickly and that the ice developing
on the surfaces insulates the water inside, causing the two to develop ice at a
very similar rate.
"Your readers should be encouraged to become scientists and test this
phenomenon themselves."
Erasto Mpemba is now Director of Game in Tanzania's Ministry
of Natural Resources.
The description of Erasto's discovery of the 'Mpemba' effect while making ice
cream is factual, based on Mpemba's story in the journal Physics
Education.
Further Reading:
The Mpemba Effect (aka Cool?) by E.B. Mpemba and D.G. Osborne, published
first in 1969 and reprinted in 1979: Phys. Educ. 1969 4 172-5,
Phys. Educ. 1979 14).
Can hot water freeze faster than cold water? by Monwhea Jeng, University of
California
Hot water freezing by Rod Nave, HyperPhysics, Georgia State University
Supercooling and the Mpemba effect, The Smithsonian/NASA Astrophysics Data
System
Knight, Charles A., The Mpemba Effect: The Freezing Times of Hot and Cold Water, Letter in Am J Phys, Vol 64, May 1996, p524
Auerbach, David, Supercooling and the Mpemba Effect: When Hot Water Freezes Faster Than Cold, Am J Phys. 63, 882-885, (1995)
J. Walker, "The Amateur Scientist", Scientific American, vol. 2337, #3, pgs
246-7, Sept. 1971)
(Answered June 8, 2008)
Comment
Readers' comments:
I read this a few years ago and devised an experiment that eliminated as many
variables as possible. Here it is:
Fill two balloons with tap water, twist the necks and clip but don’t tie them; I
used heavy-duty paper clips. Both balloons should be the same color just in case
one color might radiate faster than another.
Put both balloons in a large pot of water; heat but don’t boil. This causes
dissolved gases to come out of solution and form a small bubble.
Release the bubbles from both balloons, re-clip and weigh them. Carefully
release water, weigh again and repeat until both balloons weigh the same; the
actual weight is not important as long as they weigh the same.
Again use a pot of water and heat one balloon to the desired “hot”
temperature; I used 125F, which is typical of water from a home hot water tap.
Cool the other in a bowl of water using ice cubes to adjust the temperature; I
used 55F, which is about what water running through underground pipes might be.
Use a small “S” hook (I used bent paper clips) to hang both balloons from the
same shelf in your freezer, spacing them equally distant from the sides of the
freezer and anything else.
Periodically check for freezing progress. I just squeezed them gently, which
I think is about as valid as poking your finger in an ice-cube tray.
I ran this test twice and both times the cold water froze first.
Mike, Benton, Tennessee, USA
|
